Democracy and the Internet

Since its inception the Internet has been touted as a medium with revolutionary potential for democratic communication. Although other media including television and radio have not lived up to their democratic potential, it is too early to dismiss the Internet as being predominantly a tool for the powerful. Certainly civil society has been extraordinarily creative in using the Internet for positive social change.

Deliberation and the Internet

Although a very large number of communication venues exist in cyberspace, one critical function — deliberation — seems to have been omitted. The need for computer support for online deliberation can be shown by the fact that many online discussions seem to have no resolution at all; they often dribble off into nothingness, often leaving more confusion in their wake than before the discussion began. Worse, many online discussions degenerate into "flame wars" where online feuds make it difficult for the non-feuders to get any work done.

Roberts Rules of Order

Motivated by a desire to help make online discussions more productive — particularly among civil society groups who are striving to create more "civic intelligence" in our society — Douglas Schuler proposed in his 1996 book New Community Networks that Roberts Rules of Order could be used as a basis for online deliberation. Roberts Rules of Order was developed by Henry Robert in the late 1800s to describe an orderly process for people meeting together face-to-face to make decisions fairly. One of the most important criterion was that although every attendee would have opportunities to make his or her ideas heard the minority could not prevent the majority from making decisions. Robert labored over his "rules" for 30 years and they are now in daily use by tens of thousands of deliberative bodies worldwide. One of the interesting things that we have learned about Roberts Rules is that the process seems to scale up: small groups of 5 or so can use as can groups numbering in the hundreds.

Development at The Evergreen State College

In 1999 a team of students at The Evergreen State College developed the first prototype of an online version of Roberts Rules of Order. This was later presented at CPSR's DIAC-00 symposium by John Adams and Matt Powell. In 2003 Evergreen student Nathan Clinton, working with Schuler, designed and implemented the system which is now ready for beta-testing with actual users. Clinton and Schuler named the system eLiberate, which rhymes with deliberate (the verb).

We of course hope that eLiberate will prove as versatile as the original Roberts Rules. eLiberate is intended to be easy to use. It employs a straightforward user interface which is educational as well as facilitative. The interface shows, for example, only the legal actions that are available to the user at that specific time in the meeting. (A user can't second a motion when there is no motion to second!) At any time an "about" button can be clicked to explain what each particular action will accomplish thus providing useful cues that aren't available in face-to-face meetings. Take a look here for a transcript of a sample session.

Testing eLiberate

We at CPSRs Public Sphere Project are now beginning to work with groups who are interested in trying the system to support actual meetings. We believe that face-to-face meetings are still very important but appropriate use of eLiberate can help organizations with limited resources. Our hope is that non-profit groups will use eLiberate to save time and money on travel and use the resources they save on other activities that promote their core objectives.

We are enthusiastic about the system but we are well aware that the system as it stands may have problems that need fixing. It is for that reason that we plan to host a small number of meetings over the next few months and gather feedback from attendees. After that we plan to make eLiberate freely available for online meetings and to release the software under a free software license.


The system in its current form can support meetings that take place in real-time over an hour or so and, also, meetings that are more asynchronous (and leisurely), meetings that could, in theory, span a year or so, making it necessary for meeting attendees to log in to eLiberate once or twice a week to check for recent developments and perhaps vote or make a motion. Over the next several months we hope to study a variety of online meetings in order to adjust the system and to develop heuristics for the use of the system.

Using eLiberate

It is our intent to make eLiberate easy to use. eLiberate provides cues to permissible actions and provides online help for all features. The Use of eLiberate intended to be educational; meeting attendees should become more knowledgeable about Roberts Rules and the use of eLiberate over time through normal use of the system. Having said that, however, it is still important to acknowledge that some knowledge of — and experience with — Roberts Rules is critical to successful participation in online meetings. Groups intending to use eLiberate should work to ensure that all meeting attendees have basic understanding of the various motions and the basic rules and we have developed an online manual for that purpose. Additionally, the meeting chair should be prepared to assist attendees whenever possible. Finally, the developers will also be available to assist even though everybody currently working on this project is volunteering their time.

Thank you!

Thank you very much for your interest in eLiberate! We hope that it will help you and your organization as you strive to build a better tomorrow. Please let us know if you have any questions, concerns or ideas related to eLiberate.

Give us your thoughts!
Demonstration transcript

Draft version, Updated: February 5, 2017.
Project Goals: 
To provide a valuable service to non-profit and other groups who are working towards positive social change.